"New World drama was never simply old world plays imported for a newly constructed stage, and Dillon’s attention to the performative commons and the colonial relation will reshape critical debates in several fields for years to come. This is an important book, and one that should have a promiscuous impact on our sense of the long 18th-century Atlantic world."
- Duncan Faherty (Los Angeles Review of Books) "Taken together, Dillon's concepts not only constitute valuable analytic tools for the study of colonialism, New World slavery, and capitalism but also open up new ways to think about the politics of performance. Through its attention to detail, deft theorizations, and formulations of new critical paradigms, New World Drama offers a model for future scholarship and brings important new insights to ongoing discussions in the fields of theater and performance studies, literature, cultural studies, and history."
- Juliane Braun (William & Mary Quarterly) "Relying equally on exhaustive archival research and sharp theoretical engagements that span the disciplines of literature, performance studies, and political history,New World Drama is also, importantly, a joy to read. Dillon's real achievement here is her elegant ability to make visible the ways in which eighteenth-century politics of popular sovereignty and the aesthetics of the stage-whether Anglophone or Americanist-are inescapably haunted by the shadowy presence of Atlantic colonial relations."
- Daniel Gustafson (Eighteenth-Century Fiction) "New World Drama is, in short, the most contextually expansive, and most theoretically sophisticated, study of the early American theatre we have to date.... [The book] is a major achievement that should command the attention of all Atlanticists, and that will surely induce and provoke greater debate about theatrical culture and its performative, aesthetic and political significance. In wedding so many seemingly disparate ideas so successfully, one might say that Dillon's book finally offers a new and lasting ancestry for the 'bastard art'."
- Matthew Pethers (Symbiosis) "[Dillon's] study of two centuries of performance in the Atlantic world, keyed to specific cities, theaters, and texts, is thoughtful in synthesizing the past decade and a half of scholarship on American theater and the ways in which the theater engaged with issues of race and class. It offers a powerful vocabulary and point of entry for scholars beyond the fields of theater studies and performance studies looking for new ways to juxtapose the elusive realm of performance with the tangible world of print culture."
- Heather S. Nathans (Early American Literature) "Dillon challenges and encourages her readers to revisit familiar theoretical and historical models while at the same time expanding what it means to be interdisciplinary and transnational."
- Dana Van Kooy (BARS Review) "Students of eighteenth-century theatre will find Dillon’s scholarship to be of critical importance to their work."
- Matt DiCintio (Theatre Research International) "Through her comparative approach and focus on audiences as opposed to authors, Dillon offers fresh interpretations and reveals the extent to which reception changes the significance of play-texts."
- Helen C. Scott (Journal of American History) "... Dillon’s study is not only ambitious in its geographical and interpretative scope. It is also an important book that will shape and instigate further scholarship on early American drama for years to come. It will undoubtedly stand next to such seminal works as Paul Gilroy’s The Black Atlantic or the scholarship of Joseph Roach and Diana Taylor on intercultural performances in the Atlantic world."
- Frank Obenland (Amerikastudien)
