"Considering Watchmen takes its title seriously, presenting a thoughtful and multifaceted consideration of Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons' 12-iisue comic book series."
— American Literary History Online
"Hoberek's book, for its wealth of fascinating details and compelling arguments alone, is a useful starting point for anyone interested in the work of Alan Moore and comic book studies. More interesting, I think, and one of its finest contributions to the study of comics and literature, is the refreshing methodology it offers, which sets the stage for a rigorous historicization of realism and its relations both to its own tradition and to genre fiction."
— Image TexT
"Hoberek offers a scholarly approach to Alan Moore and David Gibson's Watchmen as a graphic novel, looking at elements most are aware of on an almost subconscious level. The author focuses on how Watchmen reached iconic status and on how it can be used as a touchstone for applying techniques from cultural studies, art studies, and literary studies to the emergent genre of the graphic novel. Overall, Hoberek does an outstanding job of injecting these fields, in addition to economics and history, into this slim overview of Watchmen. Detailed endnotes and a useful bibliography are the icing on the cake. Recommended."
— Choice
"Hoberek examines [Watchmen] from a variety of angles, crafting a well-written and well-argued series of interlocking theses. The focus on one work and dedication to formal discourse will appeal greatly to students of literature and philosophy as well as fans of serious deconstructions of popular culture."
— Library Journal
"Considering Watchmen is every conversation you've ever had about the legendary comic, straightened out and smartened up to the point that you rediscover its original force."
— J.D. Connor, Yale University
"Assiduously researched and carefully written...Considering Watchmen should be regarded as essential reading for any critic interested in the evolution of late twentieth-century print fiction."
— Modern Language Studies
"When Hoberek studies Watchmen, he does not rest in the praise of the author or in the eternal debate between the prestige category of 'Graphic novel' and the debased on of 'Comic book' ... Considering Watchmen bring[s] more perspectives to the work and thus seem[s] to confirm both the value of the originally published series and its existence as a postmodern text with multiple readings."
— The Comics Grid
"Considering Watchmen provides a series of excellent readings of its subject, a thoughtful contribution to the study of contemporary American fiction, and an admirable demonstration of the best of contemporary comics criticism."
— Postmodern Culture
"Even a thoroughly lauded and canonized work like Watchmen rests on more or less untrampled snow, and setting foot on it takes considerable nerve. Andrew Hoberek is to be commended for taking on such a daunting task."
— Cinema Journal
"This is a smart, authoritative, and nuanced book, operating at a highly sophisticated level while still remaining accessible to a wide range of readers—a true knockout punch."
— Jared Gardner, author of Projections: Comics and the History of 21st-century Storytelling
"In his erudite and fascinating study, Hoberek reveals how Watchmen, that singularity at the heart of the comic canon, rewrote our literary categories and why its disturbing visions of Apocalyptic American Superpowers continue to haunt readers decades after it first appeared."
— Junot Díaz, author of The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao
