"Appleby has produced a remarkable book. It is the most comprehensive, nuanced, and clear picture yet of American Catholic modernism. It will quickly become and long remain the standard work." —Sociology of Religion
"... the first full-length intellectual history of Catholic Modernism, American style ... this volume can be read with profit by specialists and generalists alike." —The Catholic Historical Review
"The real import of Appleby's book is its comprehensive and compassionate gathering of the strands of Catholic intellectual history from 1895-1910." —Horizons
"This is a well-reasoned and clearly written contribution to American Catholick intellecutal history....Indeed, the great strength of the book is Appleby's contant attentiveness to the relationshipo between knowledge and ecclesiastical authority." —The Journal of Religion
"Appleby makes a valuable contribution to the growing body of literature of Modernism in the U.S." —Theological Studies
"Historians of American Catholicism have been disposed to regard 'modernism' primarly as a European controversy, centering on such prominent intellectuals as the English Jesuit George Tyrrell and the french Abbé Alfred Loisy. Twenty years ago, however, in an influential articule, Michael Gannon asserted that 'counter-modernism' effectively repressed the first 'marked flowering of American Catholick clerical culture. R. Scott Appleby's book is an attempt to show what a handful of American scholar-priests in these years tried to do, how far they were influenced by prominent European modernists, why most of them abandoned scholarship in the wac of Pascendi, and why two of them (the Paulist William Sullivan, and the Josephite William Slattery) left the church." —American Historical Review
"The strength of this book is not simply in its narrative, which is fast moving and interesting, but primarily in its analysis of the publications of its subjects, and thus as an example of American Catholic intellectual history. The positions of the Catholic modernist are treated at a level comparable to Hutchinson's handling of the Protestant modernists....this is an excellent book which brings clarity and completeness to a here-to-fore muddy and partial series of events." —American Catholic Historical Society
"R. Scott Appleby's study, Church and Age Unite: The Modernist Impulse in American Catholicism contains a thoughtful account of Zahm' s life and work. For anyone interested in a well documented and articulate account of the development of both Americanism and Modernism in American Catholicism, Appleby's book is strongly recommended." —Bulletin of the Catholic Record Society
"...a core of American Catholic scholars have published studies on Modernism in its various manifestations. To this growing body of literature, Appleby has brought his own considerable research and insights. The result is the first full-length intellecual history of Catholic Modernism, American style." —Catholic Hisotrical Review
